圆明园 发表于 2007-4-2 11:53

Post by jndmtllz


香水</perfume>

刻画了没有人性的人性。 没有原著小说的恐怖感,完全的诗意化,浪漫化,夹带着点黑色幽默。 唯一可惜的是,视觉和听觉的盛宴也无法代替嗅觉的刺激。 忽然想到, 为什么没有可看,可听,可闻的电影呐?
没看过这个电影, 看过小说, 太绝了.

No-Return 发表于 2007-4-2 15:32

Post by christmas111
旅行最艰难的部分,是下决心去旅行。;)
I agree with you.

No-Return 发表于 2007-4-2 15:33

Post by 圆明园
没看过这个电影, 看过小说, 太绝了.

Oh? What is it about, please?

圆明园 发表于 2007-4-2 16:06

plot summary of Perfume: The story of a Murderer
from:IMDB

Jean-Baptiste Grenouille, born in the stench of eighteenth century Paris, develops a superior olfactory sense, which he uses to create the world's finest perfumes. His work, however, takes a dark turn as he tries to preserve scents in the search for the ultimate perfume.

No-Return 发表于 2007-4-2 16:15

Well, thank you so much! But, that is really a SUMMARY which doesn't speak quite much to me ;) . It is appreciated if you could instead give YOUR comment on why it is great.

Post by 圆明园
plot summary of Perfume: The story of a Murderer
from:IMDB

Jean-Baptiste Grenouille, born in the stench of eighteenth century Paris, develops a superior olfactory sense, which he uses to create the world's finest perfumes. His work, however, takes a dark turn as he tries to preserve scents in the search for the ultimate perfume.

christmas111 发表于 2007-4-2 19:32

Post by No-Return
Well, thank you so much! But, that is really a SUMMARY which doesn't speak quite much to me ;) . It is appreciated if you could instead give YOUR comment on why it is great.

我就不太喜欢这个电影。
不是因为变态和黑色,喜欢电影的什么变态的没看过。
我觉得首先变态得没有意义,偏要把女人弄死才能让她发出最好的香味?感觉有点自说自话。而且女人怎么会香?我觉得女人会发出香味是因为抹了香水,现在电影反过来说香水是从女人身体来的...
还有逻辑上也很奇怪,越美丽的女人,越香...sigh,身体香跟脸和三围真的有关系的么?
还有,认为香味是无敌的,还搞几百个人脱光了搞行为艺术。彻底的自说自话。
喜欢有点变态电影的可以看看,不过别期望值太高。:p
感觉上是那种不管逻辑通不通,硬塞给观众很多变态杀人镜头和裸女的典型好莱坞电影,再加点香水公司的潜在广告。

圆明园 发表于 2007-4-2 19:43

香味和美丽的关系.
有人做过研究, 是谁我不记得了, 可靠不可靠我也不知道.
找一堆穿过的内衣, 让一些女同学挑. 结果, 挑出来的全是跟女同学的基因对称的.
结论: 味道很重要.

christmas111 发表于 2007-4-2 19:52

Post by 圆明园
香味和美丽的关系.
有人做过研究, 是谁我不记得了, 可靠不可靠我也不知道.
找一堆穿过的内衣, 让一些女同学挑. 结果, 挑出来的全是跟女同学的基因对称的.
结论: 味道很重要.

味道当然很重要,但味道和香味在这里是我们讨论的2回事。

我认为人不抹香水是不会香的,我从来没有见过3天不洗澡也不抹香水还越来越香的美女。小说里老说美女“香汗淋漓”,这个当然也是搞笑一下,没有人的汗可以当香水用。

事实上如果女人是香的,要发明香水干嘛。

人不会发出香味,美女最香自然更是无稽之谈。:cool:只不过观众喜欢看裸体的美女,于是硬要这么搞一把,反正大家都高兴。

christmas111 发表于 2007-4-2 21:39

你说香就香吧,我没当过女人自然不是权威。:D
不过臭男人们一般也就在女人身上闻到洗发水,面霜,沐浴露和香水的混合气味,就算有激素的无敌清香,咱们也是一般无福享受。

No-Return 发表于 2007-4-2 22:50

Well, for this time, I think I am with Christmas:wink: . And, the comments from Chris really curbed my curiosity for that movie.

As for the topic about the link between scent and a woman, my idea is: a woman's taste and some personalities can be revealed through what scent she wears. That is, there indeed exists some subtle relation between scent and INNER beauty of a woman :wink: .
页: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 [10] 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
查看完整版本: 又看到一个有趣的电影